For induction into the CCU Athletic Hall of Fame in the Athlete category, an individual must meet all of the following criteria as outlined by the Constitution of the Hall of Fame:
- Nominee, during their undergraduate days at Coastal Carolina University, should have performed in intercollegiate athletics in a manner that is considered outstanding.
- Nominee must have demonstrated good citizenship after leaving Coastal Carolina University.
- The nominee will be eligible for nomination five (5) years after completing eligibility at Coastal Carolina University.